The Victorian Root Beer War

The Victorian Root Beer War

.

.

If you remember the 1980s, you remember “The Cola Wars“, the epic battle between Coca-Cola and Pepsi-Cola (or more “eighties-speak”: Coke and Pepsi). The Root Beer Wars of the 1890s were not a thing like the Cola Wars of the late 20th Century. No two root beer companies were in competition for supremacy. Root Beer, by the very nature of its name, fought for survival against the Temperance Movement.

.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Image: "Cola Wars"-- Pepsi and Coke are Old West gunfighters. Pepsi-Cola Ad. Courtesy of Pinterest.

“The Cola Wars”, Image: Courtesy of Pinterest.

.

.

VICTORIAN RECIPE FOR ROOT BEER

.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Cover Image of The Standard Formulary: A Collection of nearly Five Thousand Formulas, 1900.

The Standard Formulary: A Collection of Nearly Five Thousand Formulas (1900). Cover image and the entire text available digitally, courtesy of Hathi Trust.

.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Root Beer Recipe from The Standard Formulary: A Collection of Nearly Five Thousand Formulas, 1900, pg. 395.

1 of 3: Root Beer Recipe, from The Standard Formulary: A Collection of Nearly Five Thousand Formulas (1900), page 395.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Root Beer Recipe from The Standard Formulary: A Collection of Nearly Five Thousand Formulas, 1900, pg. 395. Part 2.

2 of 3: Root Beer Recipe from The Standard Formulary: A Collection of Nearly Five Thousand Formulas (1900), p. 395.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Root Beer Recipe from The Standard Formulary: A Collection of Nearly Five Thousand Formulas, 1900, pg. 395. Part 3.

3 of 3: Root Beer Recipe from The Standard Formulary: A Collection of Nearly Five Thousand Formulas (1900), p. 395.

.

The methods by which the extract for root beer is created involves fermentation. I can see why the “Temperance Ladies”, if ill-informed (or on a rampage), would object. Perhaps loudly. Read on, to see what the Women’s Christian Temperance Union had to say about Hires Root Beer.

.

.

HIRES ROOT BEER

.

NOW

.

Hires is a brand consumers recognize in the twenty-first century. This Victorian brand is familiar as Hires Root Beer is still for sale.

.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Hires Root Beer, currently for sale on Amazon.

Hires Root Beer, currently for sale on Amazon.com.

.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Root Beer Extract, currently for sale on Amazon.

Root Beer Extract, available today. See Amazon.

.

THEN~ Victorian

.

The following advertisement from 1882 promoted Hires Root Beer, 25¢ for a package that makes 5 gallons of the touted “Temperance Beverage“.

.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Advertisement for Hires Improved Root Beer, The Daily Review of Wilmington, North Carolina. March 27, 1882.

Hires Improved Root Beer. The Daily Review of Wilmington, North Carolina. March 27, 1882.

.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Hires Rootbeer: Full of Snap, Sparkle and Vim. Full of Good health. Full of everything good. An effervescent temperance beverage. The Salt Lake Tribune of Salt Lake City, Utah Territory, 24 June 1895.

Hires Rootbeer [sic]: Full of Snap, Sparkle and Vim. Full of Good health. Full of everything good. An effervescent temperance beverage. The Salt Lake Tribune of Salt Lake City, Utah Territory, 24 June 1895.

.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Photograph of Hires Root Beer Extract, corked, 3 oz. bottle. 1929 Vintage. Photo courtesy of sales page of ebay.

3 oz. bottle of Hires Root Beer Extract, corked. 1929 vintage. Currently for sale on ebay.

.

The Hires Rootbeer [sic] of 1897 advertisement suggests that Hires Rootbeer cools drinkers off in the heat of the sun, keeps people well, and quenches the thirst.

.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Hires Root Beer Ad, illustrated. Published in the Manhattan Mercury of Manhattan, Kansas, June 2, 1897.

Advertisement for Hires Root Beer, published in the Manhattan Mercury of Manhattan, Kansas on June 2, 1897.

.

.

HIRES ROOT BEER: A TEMPERANCE BEVERAGE

.

Kristin Holt | A Victorian Root Beer War. Illustrated Ad for Hires Root Beer, a Temperance Drink. St. Louis Post-Dispatch, St. Louis, Missouri, April 28, 1893.

Hires Root Beer, a Temperance Drink. St. Louis Post-Dispatch, St. Louis, Missouri, April 28, 1893.

.

Ethan Trex, a writer for Mental Floss, shares Hires Root Beer history and the charming consequences of this delicious beverage. After all, it’s ALL in a name! According to this fun article, Hires wasn’t a drinker (of alcohol) and didn’t want anybody thinking his “root tea” contained intoxicants.

.

One of his mentors disagreed, though. Russell Conwell, a Baptist minister and the first president of Temple University, told Hires that he’d never make any money with something called “root tea.” The blue collar miners in the area wouldn’t be caught dead drinking a little tea. Now, root beer–there was a rough-and-tumble name that would catch on.

.

The Baptist preacher’s advice to the teetotaling Quaker turned out to be sound. Hires gave away free mugs of root beer at the 1876 Centennial Exposition in Philly, and he was on his way to becoming America’s first soft drink millionaire.

.

~ How the Temperance Movement Almost Killed Root Beer, by Ethan Trex, Mental Floss

.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Hires Root Beer proudly pronounces itself a Temperance Beverage in Tyrone Daily herald of Tyorne, PA. 22 June 1893.

Hires Root Beer proudly pronounces itself a Temperance Beverage, in Tyrone Daily Herald of Tyrone, Pennsylvania, on June 22, 1893.

.

.

HIRES ROOT BEER CAUGHT IN “TEMPERANCE WARS”

.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Question as to whether Root Beer contains alcohol. Salina Daily Republican-Journal of Salina, Kansas. June 18, 1897.

As to the question… does Root Beer contain alcohol? Salina Daily Republican-Journal of Salina, Kansas. June 18, 1897.

.

Then, something funny happened. The “root beer” name Conwell had suggested came back to bite Hires. In 1895, the Women’s Christian Temperance Union turned its sights on Hires, partially because  of the word “beer” in the name. …the WCTU theorized that since his root beer was a sweet fermented beverage it must have some booze in it. (Chemistry apparently wasn’t the WCTU’s strong suit). Thus, having a frosty root beer was no better than pounding back a godforsaken actual beer.

.

Instead of testing to see if there was actually any alcohol in Hires’ root beer, the WCTU simply called for a nationwide ban on his product, which had become wildly popular in drugstores around the country.

.

~ How the Temperance Movement Almost Killed Root Beer, by Ethan Trex, Mental Floss

.

Laughable, now, isn’t it? That WCTU crusade lasted three whole years (1895 to 1898), and was finally settled by the same kind of independent lab verification (and sworn statements published far and wide) as Coca-Cola would have to do about five years later, to divorce itself once and for all from the stain of cocaine.

.

Kristin Holt | The Victorian Root Beer War. Cover art: Sundae Best: History of Soda Fountains by Anne Cooper Funderburg. For sale on Amazon.

.

.

.

.

Related Articles

.

Kristin Holt | DIY Yeast in Victorian America

Kristin Holt | Victorian Dr. Pepper (1885)

Kristin Holt | New at the Soda Fountain: Pepsi-Cola (1898)

Kristin Holt | Cocaine in Victorian Coca-Cola: Going... Going... Gone?

Kristin Holt | Victorian Coca-Cola Gains Popularity... and Critics (Cocaine in my Soda Water?)

Kristin Holt | New Coca-Cola: Branded, Bottled, Corked, and only 5 cents!

Kristin Holt | New at the Soda Fountain: Coca-Cola!

Kristin Holt | Soda Fountain: 19th Century Courtship

Kristin Holt | The Soda Fountain: Behind the Counter

Kristin Holt | The Victorian-era Soda Fountain

Kristin Holt | June 20th: National Ice Cream Soda Day! Not your Victorian Ice Cream Sodas.

.

.

Updated March 2021
Copyright © 2017 Kristin Holt LC
The Victorian Root Beer War